William J.Harris x Romare Bearden’s “The Black Card Players”

What Dr. Harris is doing in this poem is interesting. While he could have easily deployed it as a paragraph of jagged prose, he decided to linebreak, enjamb, and pump fake toward a poem.  Harris’s speaker is both reporting and opining about what they see, but also welcomes us into questioning what we might see.

While the speaker draws contrasts about the actions of the card players, the speaker zooms out to look at both paintings. In the second to last stanza Harris’s speaker notes,

In Bearden’s
More
Colorful
World
Nobody
Interacts
Either

drawing the comparison of the palettes of both of Cezanne’s and Bearden’s card players.

When I think of how Black poetries can exist as a kind of critical language when talking about Black art,  I think this kind of observing and “poeming” could be that. While Harris’s poem may be a very basic example, I like what is accomplished with so few words…the questions asked, the description of what we see, the comparison of the colors chosen by the artists, what the people in the image are doing…Harris covers a lot of ground and asks us to look again, look deeper.

The Black Card Players: A Collage

Bearden’s card players
In some ways
Differ from Cézanne’s
In Cézanne
All
Three men
Intensely stare
At their
Cards
Their cards
Are their
Only world
In Bearden
Two card
Players
Stare
At their
Cards
Intensely
The third
Vacantly stares
Out
Toward us
But not looking
At us
His cards
Flat on the table
Does he have a bad
Hand or
Is he thinking
About his father’s
Impending
Death?
In Cézanne
The spectators
Pay no attention
To the game
Stare off
Musing on
Their own lives
In Bearden
No spectators
A waitress (?)
Brings
A glass
Of red
Wine
Possible joy
But
In Bearden’s
More
Colorful
World
Nobody
Interacts
Either
All are
Lost
In their
Own thoughts
Notes:
This poem was previously published in Catamaran Literary Reader (2013) and is reprinted here by permission of William J. Harris. It is part of the portfolio “I Hope You Like Being Here with Me: The Work of William J. Harris,” curated by Howard Rambsy II.
Source: Poetry (February 2023)
https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poetrymagazine/poems/159465/the-black-card-players-a-collage

Categories: